Realtors™ in Lexington

Compare the best real estate Agents and Realtors™

Top Real Estate Agents, Brokers and Realtors in Lexington

Mary Layton photo
Kitty Lane photo

Best Realtors™ in Lexington | Photos & Reviews


Kitty Lane

The Lane Team

Kitty Lane is an expert manager who leads the Lane Team in Lexington, and she consistently earns stellar reviews across various online platforms. She is among the Top 1.5% of brokers nationwide and a Lifetime Member of the Lexington-Bluegrass Association of Realtors' Top Producers' Club. What's remarkable about Kitty is that she prioritizes every client's dream with a personal touch and treats each vision as if it were her own. Customers adore working with her team because of their infectious enthusiasm. With four decades of experience, Kitty Lane has established herself as a trusted figure in the real estate realm by coupling wisdom and experience with unwavering moral principles.
Michael B.

Michael B. Prather

Keller Williams Bluegrass Realty

Michael B. Prather, CEO of The Prather Team, brings over four decades of real estate expertise through Keller Williams Bluegrass Realty. Michael's love for Central Kentucky, his birthplace and current residence, shines through as a Middle Tennessee State University graduate with a BBA in Computer Information Systems. Michael leads The Prather Team, providing unparalleled expertise for buyers seeking dream homes or sellers maximizing profits, prioritizing exceptional customer service since 2012 alongside Katy Prather. With hundreds of positive reviews, The Prather Team consistently holds the #1 position among residential real estate teams in Central Kentucky and ranks #3 in the Ohio Valley.

Bob Sophiea

New Home Collective

Bob Sophiea, Founder and CEO of New Home Collective since 2014, has transformed real estate with almost 2,000 homes sold and has earned over 900 5-star Google reviews. His expertise, social media presence, and innovative approach attract clients and professionals. As a skilled negotiator who prioritizes transparency and communication, Bob ensures the best outcomes for clients. His punctuality, collaboration, continuous learning, and self-awareness fuel his success, and under his leadership, New Home Collective redefines the home buying and selling experience.

Rusty Underwood

Christie's International Real Estate Bluegrass

Award-winning Kentucky real estate luminary Rusty Underwood commands the local market with unparalleled expertise. Renowned for leadership, he not only serves on the National Association of Realtors Finance Committee but is also a prestigious lifetime member of the Million-Dollar Club. Rusty exemplifies true leadership and unwavering dedication as president of both Bluegrass Realtors and the Community Housing Foundation. Beyond facilitating seamless home transactions, he showcases versatility in investments and remodeling. Rusty is the go-to professional for handling any property type with unrivaled excellence, with a proven track record, diverse expertise, and a string of accolades including being the #1 producing Realtor® for Fayette County (2016-2021).

Whitney Durham

Bluegrass Sotheby's International Realty

Lexington native Whitney Durham, a seasoned real estate expert with 22 years of dedicated experience, is a passionate advocate for her beloved city. Whitney's knowledge of the entire region is extensive, extending to every neighborhood detail. She achieved an impressive $316 million in sales between 2020 and 2021 as one of the state's top brokers, earning recognition as the #1 Single-Producing Agent in Central Kentucky. Whitney's success stems from unwavering dedication and resilience, traits that propel her through the complexities of real estate transactions. Her love for Lexington and commitment to excellence make Whitney Durham the go-to professional for navigating the dynamic real estate landscape in Central Kentucky.

Becky Reinhold

Bluegrass Sotheby's International Realty

For more than 39 years, Becky Reinhold has provided superior real estate services in the Lexington area. She was named one of the Top 15 Producing Realtors® in the state. With her extensive market knowledge, Becky has assisted thousands of families and individuals with buying, selling, and investing in a variety of property types. Many clients have benefited from her help in making the transition to the next phase of their lives. In her free time, Becky makes it a point to support and give back to her community by getting involved in charitable endeavors.

Mary Layton

F.C. Tucker/Bluegrass

With over 40 years of real estate expertise, Mary Layton, Broker and Owner of FC Tucker Bluegrass, is renowned for exceptional customer service. Founding the Mary Layton Group in 2018 and associated with Milestone Realty Consultants, she's a distinguished professional with ABR, ALHS, CNHS, CRS, e-PRO, GRI, SFR, SRES, and SRS credentials. Mary's accomplishments include Executive and Presidents Circle Awards, confirming her position as a top producer in new home sales. The Mary Layton Group provides exceptional real estate services in the Lexington, Georgetown, Richmond, Winchester, and Nicholasville areas, exemplifying Mary's dedication to excellence and proficiency in matching homes with their ideal owners.

Melinda Duncan

RE/MAX Creative Realty

A breath of fresh air in the real estate arena, Melinda Duncan, radiates confidence, cheerfulness, and enthusiasm, all while maintaining a soothing sense of calm. Melinda has honed the art of fostering harmonious client-agent relationships that are both formal and hospitable over her impressive 35 years of experience, putting her consistently in high demand. Over a decade ago, she achieved the remarkable feat of becoming the #1 RE/MAX Realtor® in Kentucky, a title she has retained as Lexington's top producer, amassing over 20 awards in the process. Melinda's enduring success and accolades underscore her unparalleled expertise and dedication to excellence in serving the real estate needs of her clients.

Suzanne Elliott

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices de Movellan Properties

For more than 20 years, Suzanne Elliott has been one of Lexington's top brokers. She is a Certified Residential Specialist, a Graduate of the REALTOR® Institute, an Accredited Buyer’s Representative, and a designated expert in many other real estate-related fields. Suzanne works with integrity and prides herself on being truthful and fair. She won't let anyone take advantage of her, even as a seller's agent working toward a high yield. Collaborating with Suzanne is a pleasure because she is dependable and sincere. In addition, she is committed to upholding the highest standards of ethics.

Judy Craft

Milestone Realty Consultants

Judy Craft is known for her dependability and ensures a seamless experience from start to finish. With a wealth of experience in sales, marketing, and home construction, she adds reassurance to every interaction. Judy holds the prestigious e-Pro designation and has professional training in online marketing tools. Satisfied customers have acknowledged her as "the perfect client representative" for her unmatched service. She has been licensed in Kentucky since 1985, and as a broker since 1990, and is a member of several industry associations. Judy's impressive array of designations includes Accredited Buyer Representative, Certified Residential Specialist, Certified New Home Specialist, Certified New Home Sales Professional, Graduate Realtor Institute, and E-PRO.

Sandy Allnutt

The Allnutt Group

Founded by Sandy Allnutt over a decade ago, The Allnutt Group is a testament to her 33 years of real estate prowess in Kentucky. Originally from Germany, Sandy has earned the distinction of being the #2 broker in the state, with a recent accolade as RateMyAgent's Top Agent in Fayette County for 2021. Sandy continually sets new records as a consistent top producer and a lifetime member of the Million-Dollar Club. She holds numerous accreditations in various real estate specialties and knows how to seamlessly navigate any transaction. Above all, Sandy is driven by a genuine desire to assist her customers in finding the home of their dreams, making The Allnutt Group a trusted name.
Shane T.

Shane T. Underwood

Underwood Group

Led by Shane Underwood, The Underwood Group stands as a multimillion-dollar-producing real estate team in Lexington. In 2020, this dynamic team of agents achieved an impressive milestone, closing 72 deals totaling an astounding $14 million. Shane's leadership places the team at an impressive #11 in production within their firm, boasting an average property selling time of just 39 days. Shane ensures the team's sterling reputation by maintaining high standards and providing exceptional customer service. Shane, holding a degree in business administration and management from Morehead State University, continues to drive the team towards even higher goals, solidifying The Underwood Group as a powerhouse in the Lexington real estate market.

Nick Ratliff

The Lexpert

Nick Ratliff, an esteemed Associate Broker at The Lexpert in Lexington, KY, boasts an impressive 16-year career in real estate. He champions the profound impact of connections in the industry as the founder of Cypress Residential Group in 2010 and the architect of the Nick Ratliff Realty Team in 2012. A University of Kentucky graduate in Electrical Engineering and Business Administration, Nick seamlessly integrates technical prowess with personalized service. A trailblazer in social networking for marketing, he embraces technological evolution, positioning himself at the vanguard of innovative real estate practices. Nick's unwavering dedication to individual client representation and the provision of genuine 5-Star Service exemplifies his commitment to professionalism and excellence in this dynamic field.

Michelle Gunter

Bluegrass Home Group

Renowned in Lexington, Michelle Gunter stands as a highly reputable agent, showcasing unparalleled expertise in marketing and negotiation. A master of the art of buying and selling, Michelle consistently claims the top-performing agent spot for homes sold in her firm since the start of her career. She credits her success to unwavering dedication and hard work, and she consistently ranks in the top 1% of brokers in the Bluegrass Association of Realtors. Michelle founded Bluegrass Home Group in 2015 and her dedication to providing the best service in the industry is clear. Her love for the job is matched only by her promise to work tirelessly around the clock until each transaction is completed.

Jenny Mateyoke

Keller Williams Legacy Group

Jenny Mateyoke is a distinguished authority on the Lexington market who strategically navigates the real estate landscape with an in-depth understanding of buying and selling trends. As a Certified Real Estate Negotiator and Certified Tourism Ambassador, Jenny is well-equipped to handle various property types and ensure success in the current economic climate. Her tireless work ethic and attention to detail, coupled with a laser-like focus on each client, yield exceptional results. Beyond her professional prowess, Jenny actively engages with her community, extending a helping hand to numerous nonprofits and aiding those in need. With a commitment to excellence and community service, Jenny is a trusted and dedicated figure in the Lexington real estate scene.

Deborah Back

The Back Team

As both an Accredited Buyer's Representative and a Certified Residential Specialist, Deborah Back combines expertise with a genuine passion for her work, leading The Back Team for an impressive 36 years in real estate. This top-producing team prioritizes client satisfaction throughout transactions, guided by shared values and unwavering ethics. Deborah's leadership underscores the importance of placing clients at the forefront, recognizing that the heart's influence surpasses technical expertise. In the past 12 months alone, she has successfully closed deals on 14 properties, a testament to her enduring commitment to excellence and client-centric service in the dynamic realm of real estate.

Paul Chartier

The Agency

Paul Chartier, an esteemed Realtor®, brings a distinctive blend of education and experience, positioning him as the ideal choice for all real estate needs. Paul's knowledge and expertise, backed by a Master of Business Administration from Bellarmine University, seamlessly guide clients through even the most complex transactions. As a top producer, he boasts a proven track record of success, setting him apart from the competition. Working with Paul ensures clients are in good hands, as he is dedicated to delivering the results they deserve. Committed to making the buying or selling process as stress-free as possible, Paul Chartier stands out as a trusted professional committed to excellence in the real estate realm.

Andrea Coughtry

Keller Williams Greater Lexington

As a top-producing real estate agent, Andrea Coughtry boasts a consistently outstanding annual sales record and has held the prestigious title of Million Dollar Producer since 2016. Andrea is a Kentucky native and full-time real estate professional, and her extensive experience and knowledge place her as the best choice in today's competitive real estate market. Beyond her thriving career, Andrea owns and manages a real estate portfolio nearing $4.3 million, leading a team responsible for properties valued at nearly $9 million. With a commitment to exceeding expectations, forming lifelong client relations, and making the real estate process enjoyable, Andrea delivers dreams in her full-time career.

Jenny Hukill

RE/MAX Elite Realty

Jenny Hukill is a top-producing real estate agent affiliated with RE/MAX that has a proven track record of achievement. She received honors every year, including membership in the Executive Club in 2018 and 2016 as well as the 100% Club in 2021, 2020, 2019 and 2017. However, Jenny's commitment to her clients goes beyond her success in the real estate industry. In Lexington's very competitive real estate market, Jenny is a prominent player who is renowned for her wit and nimbleness. She participates actively in the Children's Leader Bible Study Fellowship, demonstrating her dedication to the neighborhood and to assisting others.

Kimberly Holtegel

ERA Select Real Estate

Dedicated to guiding clients to their ideal residences, Kimberly Holtegel, a passionate real estate expert with ERA Select Real Estate in Lexington, Kentucky, consistently delivers the utmost service excellence, going above and beyond to ensure her clients' happiness at every step. She caters to a wide range of real estate needs, with a $58 million sales record spanning a price range of $138,000 to $875,000 and an average price of $269,800. Kim is the ideal choice for first-time homebuyers and experienced investors alike, providing knowledge, professionalism, and a customer-centered experience. Leveraging her personal experience in buying and selling homes, she guides clients towards their next fantastic investment.

Donna Elder

RE/MAX Creative Realty

Donna Elder stands out as a distinguished agent at RE/MAX, prioritizing clients' financial well-being. With over 35 years of experience, her focus extends beyond awards to a passion for assisting diverse clients. From guiding first-time buyers to aiding those transitioning to assisted living or handling probate matters, Donna's commitment shines. Specializing in various real estate facets, including move-ups and downsizing, she dedicates time to addressing clients' questions and concerns. With a comprehensive skill set and unwavering availability, Donna Elder is NEVER too busy for you and your real estate questions.

Robin Jones

Keller Williams Legacy Group

Robin Jones is a seasoned real estate professional with a track record of success and a passion for helping her clients achieve their real estate goals. As a member of the KW Legacy Group, Robin has been an integral part of the team's success, contributing to their recognition as the 2017 #1 Team in Production and the 2017 #1 Listing Team. Robin has been recognized for her achievements in the industry, receiving the 2017 KW Regional Award for Top Individual for Profit Share Tree Growth. This award reflects Robin's dedication to helping others achieve success in their real estate careers and her ability to build strong relationships with her colleagues.

Roger Browning

Four Seasons Realty

Roger Browning, a knowledgeable and skilled Realtor® and owner of Four Seasons Realty LLC in Lexington, Kentucky, leads a dynamic team alongside his wife, Christal Browning. The duo has sold over 1200 homes as top Realtors® in the Lexington area, demonstrating their extensive industry experience. Roger, ranking among the top 1% of Realtors®, and his team stand out as leaders in the Lexington-Central Kentucky real estate market. With a proven track record, they prioritize clients' needs, working diligently to protect their interests, negotiate effectively, and offer expert advice. Roger Browning and his team stand out as the clear and dependable choice for those looking to buy or sell property in Central Kentucky.

Whitney Pannell

Team Pannell Real Estate

Whitney Pannell is a name that resonates with excellence and trustworthiness in the Lexington, Kentucky, real estate market. With over $400,000,000 in lifetime sales, Whitney has established herself as a top-producing agent with a remarkable track record spanning nearly three decades. Her profound understanding of the local market, coupled with her commitment to quality, has earned her a reputation as a trusted Realtor® who helps clients make informed real estate decisions. Whitney's success record and unwavering dedication to providing the highest level of service make her an invaluable resource for anyone seeking to navigate the intricacies of the Lexington real estate market.

Steve Klein

Bluegrass Sotheby's International Realty

Steve Klein is a successful and respected figure in real estate with over 37 years of industry expertise. Based in Central Kentucky, he has built a solid reputation for his honesty, humor, and unwavering commitment to his clients. Steve's sharp negotiation skills, vast network of industry connections, unmatched knowledge of the local real estate market, and extensive financial experience make him an ideal partner for those seeking to navigate today's competitive market. He is widely recognized for his ability to deliver exceptional results for his clients, consistently ranking among the top 1% of agents in the region. Clients appreciate Steve's honest and straightforward approach, and his peers admire his ability to close transactions successfully.

Meredith Walker

Bluegrass Sotheby's International Realty

With a decade of sales expertise and a robust background in Lexington's corporate sector, Meredith Walker navigates Central Kentucky's real estate market with finesse. She is dedicated to honesty and transparency, guiding buyers through home-buying and assisting sellers with strategic pricing and marketing. Meredith understands the importance of finding the perfect home as a dedicated mother and advocate for the Lexington area, working tirelessly to make her clients' dreams a reality. Boasting a sales history of 209 closed transactions totaling $86 million, spanning a price range of $194,000 to $1.6 million, Meredith specializes in Lexington's luxury real estate market, making her an invaluable resource for diverse real estate needs.

David Stewart

Christie's International Real Estate Bluegrass

David Stewart has been a licensed Realtor® since 1984 and has developed a deep understanding of the Central Kentucky area. He has helped his clients buy and sell single-family homes, with a combined value exceeding $130 million dollars. He specializes in Ball Homes for the Lexington area and has extensive experience with new construction. David uses his expertise to assist homebuyers in finding their dream home that meets their needs and fits within their budget. He is highly regarded for his reliable, honest, and knowledgeable service throughout the home-buying process, earning the trust of his clients over the years.

Susie Rodes

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices de Movellan Properties

A distinguished sixth-generation Lexington resident and seasoned real estate professional, Susie Rodes possesses an unparalleled understanding of the local market. She has 27 years of experience in buying and selling properties, and assisting clients in securing starter homes to luxurious golf course estates. As the founder of Bluegrass Home Group in 2015, Susie's commitment to providing the best service is evident. She has received Chairman's Circle awards and numerous accolades, including the 2019 Gold Total GCI, and she consistently ranks in the top 2% of the company. Susie's deep-rooted knowledge, exceptional service, and continuous recognition make her the go-to choice for all real estate needs in the region.
Background image

Find the perfect Realtors™ for you!


Lexington is home to Transylvania University and the University of Kentucky. It has over 327,000 residents and is referred to as the World's Horse Capital. The city is close to many amenities found in larger regions and is home to 130 schools. Lexington's property market is advantageous for sellers, per Realtor.com's annual analysis, as demand is rising and supply is decreasing. The median home sales price of $370,000 last December 2023 is still relatively low and ideal for investments. Some of the top Lexington neighborhoods that Sparefoot recommends are Chevy Chase, Beaumont, and Kenwick. Finding the ideal Realtor® doesn't need to be a concern. The top brokers in the area are listed below.

About Us

Welcome to Real Estate Insights Magazine – where the vast and dynamic world of real estate comes alive on every page! Established in [Year], our magazine has been at the forefront of delivering insightful, up-to-date information to real estate professionals, investors, and home enthusiasts alike. Our Mission: We are dedicated to providing our readers with comprehensive coverage of the latest trends, market analyses, and success stories in the real estate sector. Our goal is to inform, inspire, and influence the real estate community, from seasoned experts to those just stepping into this exciting field.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you rank real estate agents?

At triple we use proprietary algorithms we developed over years. We consider many data points including, but not limited to: the most up-to-date transaction data, customer reviews, work history.

What makes your site different from other real estate websites?

1. We don’t allow advertising, enabling us to have no conflicts of interest and to operate independently (we are only paid when we match clients and Realtors™). 2. We do original and independent research. In fact we call Realtors™ and customers and gather original insights. 3. We are data driven technologists. We are computer scientists using algorithms and AI to create actionable rankings and insights from our massive proprietary data set.

Can agents pay to be featured?

No. We do our own independent ranking. Our reason for existing is to provide buyers and sellers with the resources to find their best Realtor™ match. In this way everyone wins. Transactions are faster and smoother, customers get better deals, brokers get more business, we gain more referrals.

How often do you update your rankings?

We do an annual overhaul of our top list; however, we are constantly gathering data and evaluating new information. Thus agents are added and removed all year round.